The Rise of Skywalker was supposed to close the Skywalker saga, but its ending has never stopped being an argument. Now a Collider ranking has put the 2019 film back under the microscope. This time, the question goes well beyond whether J.J. Abrams delivered a satisfying final chapter. The headline asks us to judge Episode IX against the entire history of science-fiction movies.
What the Collider List Actually Ranked
In Safwan Azeem’s November 3, 2026 ranking, “The 10 Worst Sci-Fi Movies in Film History,” The Rise of Skywalker takes the No. 1 spot. Movie 43 is No. 2, followed by the 2015 Fantastic Four at No. 3.
That is a real placement in a published list. It is not an industry award, a survey result, or an objective verdict handed down by everyone working at Collider. It is one writer’s ranking, and the distinction matters when a judgment this broad becomes the headline.
The Episode IX entry focuses on familiar complaints: Palpatine’s return, the revelation that Rey is his granddaughter, Finn’s unfinished attempt to tell Rey something, and a conclusion that feels rushed. Those are specific storytelling objections, not simply a complaint that the film contains spaceships and lightsabers.
Still, identifying weaknesses and proving an all-time bottom spot are different jobs. A review can make a strong case that a movie fails its own story without making an equally strong case that nothing in its genre has ever been worse.

The Biggest Problems Are About How the Story Ends
Bringing back Palpatine puts an enormous burden on the final film. The Emperor’s return on Exegol is part of the story, not a theory. Whether that comeback is dramatically convincing is a separate question.
Episode IX needs to establish him as the final threat, connect him to Rey, and bring the Resistance’s war to a close. Meanwhile, it must finish Ben Solo’s story and give the remaining heroes meaningful farewells. That is a lot of work for one movie, especially when its central villain needs a fresh explanation for being there at all.
The problem is not that Star Wars suddenly includes an impossible survival. This is a series built around extraordinary powers. The harder question is whether the return feels earned by the preceding story, rather than introduced because the finale needs a bigger enemy.
Rey’s parentage creates a similar tension. Her connection to Palpatine and her eventual choice of the Skywalker name give the film a clear theme: ancestry does not decide who you become. There is an understandable emotional idea there.
But revealing another famous family connection also changes the weight of her earlier search for belonging. Instead of letting that search rest, the final chapter adds a new answer and asks the ending to make it meaningful almost immediately. You can appreciate the theme while finding the route to it awkward.
Finn’s interrupted confession is a smaller example of the same issue. The film draws attention to something he wants to say, but does not give that conversation a clear on-screen finish. Not every unanswered question is a plot hole. Even so, setting up a personal moment and leaving it hanging can make a final chapter feel less complete.
However, “Worst Ever” Needs More Than a Disappointing Finale
Failing as a saga ending is not automatically the same as failing at every part of filmmaking.
A sequel arrives with expectations that a standalone film does not carry. It inherits relationships, promises, and unresolved conflicts. If the conclusion mishandles them, the disappointment can reach backward into earlier installments. That makes the experience personal in a way that watching an unrelated bad movie rarely is.
But emotional disappointment is only one possible measure. An all-time ranking also invites questions about performances, staging, visual storytelling, pacing, originality, and whether individual sequences work. If franchise expectations are doing most of the work, the list is closer to a ranking of letdowns than a comparison of science-fiction cinema as a whole.
There is also a selection problem worth noticing. Putting Movie 43, a collection of comedy sketches, at No. 2 raises questions about how the list defines its field. That does not automatically invalidate every choice, but it makes the scope less clear than the sweeping title suggests.
Star Wars does not need a genre exemption to escape the argument. Its space-fantasy elements do not make the comparison forbidden; the official film page includes science fiction among its genres. The more useful question is what standard connects these selections, and why Episode IX lands below all of them.
The original final trailer is a useful reminder of the job this film was selling: not simply another adventure, but the end of the saga. That promise helps explain the scale of the disappointment without settling an all-time ranking.
There Is Still a Movie Here Beyond the Controversial Twists
The duel on the Death Star wreckage is a good place to start. Its waves, unstable footing, and exposed setting give the confrontation a physical danger that feels different from a clean arena fight. Rey and Kylo Ren are not just exchanging blows; the scene leads into the possibility that Ben can still change.
That is not an invented defense added years later. Owen Gleiberman’s December 2019 Variety review praised both the duel’s visual force and its emotional turn. His review was strongly positive overall. That does not cancel Azeem’s judgment, but it gives us a concrete example of a professional critic finding substantial value in the same film.
Smaller scenes offer a different kind of appeal. In Babu Frik’s workshop, C-3PO faces losing his memories so the group can obtain the information it needs. The joke-prone, anxious droid briefly becomes the person making the sacrifice. His pause to look at his friends gives an otherwise busy quest room to breathe.
The memory-wipe scene and Rey’s final choice on Tatooine were also explored as highlights in a 2020 StarWars.com essay. That is an interpretation of their emotional value, not proof that everyone must find them moving.
There is a fair objection even here: restoring C-3PO’s memory later softens the lasting cost. But that is precisely why a useful discussion can hold two ideas at once. A scene can be well performed and emotionally effective while the larger script weakens its consequences.
You Don’t Have to Defend Everything to Reject No. 1
The strongest objection to this ranking does not require pretending the ending is flawless. Palpatine’s comeback can feel underdeveloped. Rey’s new family connection can feel unnecessary. Ben’s final act can be moving while the time given to its aftermath feels too short.
Those are judgments about particular choices. They leave room to explain what failed, what worked, and why the balance matters. “Worst science-fiction movie in film history” compresses all of that into one enormous claim.
Azeem is entitled to make that claim. The placement is opinion, however, not a new fact about the film’s quality. You can dislike Episode IX as the conclusion to Star Wars and still find the comparison unconvincing. A broken promise at the end of a beloved saga is a serious criticism. It is not, by itself, an all-time ranking.
