Skip to Content

We Really Understate How Immoral and Tragic the Republic’s Use of the Clone Army Was

We Really Understate How Immoral and Tragic the Republic’s Use of the Clone Army Was

In the Legends comic Orders, a clone commando named Sarge finds a boy whose parents were killed after a Republic bombing hit civilian territory. Later, around a campfire, Evan tells the squad how he lost his family, and Sarge tells him that the clones never had parents or a home to begin with. The next morning, Evan watches the squad shoot its Jedi general under Order 66. In the space of one night, he sees what the clones do for people and what their orders can make them do.

Clone commando Sarge talks with Evan, a boy who lost his parents during the Clone Wars
Sarge and Evan in Orders, from Clone Wars Adventures Volume 4 (Legends). Dark Horse / Lucasfilm.

The Republic Got an Army. The Clones Lost a Childhood.

When Obi-Wan tours Kamino in Attack of the Clones, Lama Su talks about the soldiers like he’s showing off a product. The Kaminoans can bring them to maturity in about half the usual time, and they’ve altered their genes to make them less independent than Jango Fett. Lama Su is proud of both changes. The sooner the clones grow up, the sooner they can take orders.

Boba Fett makes that scene even harder to watch. Jango asked for an unaltered clone to raise as his son, so Boba gets a father and grows up at a normal pace. The boys Obi-Wan sees in training have the same genetic template, but their childhood is spent preparing for combat. When Lama Su talks about saving time, it’s their time he’s saving the Republic.

The Republic didn’t have to commission the army itself to benefit from that arrangement. Once it put the clones on the front lines, it accepted the idea that these men already owed it their service. The clones could take pride in what they did and still deserve a say in whether they did it at all.

Cut Lawquane Had to Desert to Have an Ordinary Life

In “The Deserter,” an injured Rex recovers on a farm on Saleucami and meets Cut Lawquane. Cut lives there with his wife, Suu, and their children, Jek and Shaeeah. To Rex, he’s a deserter. To his family, he’s the person they count on to come home.

Cut tells Rex that Separatist gunships attacked his transport after Geonosis. He saw his brothers die and escaped while droids were killing the wounded. After that, he couldn’t see a reason to go back and wait for his turn. When commando droids threaten the farm, though, Cut picks up a weapon to defend his family. He still has the courage the army trained into him. Now he gets to decide what’s worth fighting for.

All clone trooper Cut Lawquane scenes - The Clone Wars, The Bad Batch

Rex’s reaction is understandable. Walking away would mean leaving brothers behind who still have to fight. That’s part of what makes the dinner-table argument so good. Both men know what it’s like to watch brothers die, and they come away with different ideas of what they owe the army. Rex eventually leaves without reporting Cut. For now, Cut gets to keep his home because one officer decides to let him.

The Jedi Could Care About the Clones and Still Make Use of Them

The clones pick names, paint their armor and build real friendships with the people they serve. Watching Anakin trust Rex or Ahsoka worry about her troops gives those relationships weight. A Jedi who cares about the men under their command can make their lives better. Those men still have to serve under whoever comes next.

On Kamino, Shaak Ti refuses to let Nala Se kill Tup to examine his body. Shaak Ti argues that the Jedi are responsible for his care. Nala Se replies that the clones’ genetic makeup is Kaminoan property. While the two argue over who has authority, Fives insists on something simpler. Tup has a name, and he needs help.

Shaak Ti speaks with Fives beside a medical droid on Kamino
Shaak Ti and Fives on Kamino in The Clone Wars. Lucasfilm / StarWars.com.

On Umbara, Pong Krell tells two clone units that the enemy is wearing stolen clone armor. They fire on each other until Rex pulls off a fallen soldier’s helmet and realizes who they’ve been shooting. Krell can set that trap because the men have been trained to trust the orders they’re given. When they finally arrest him, they have to turn against their own commanding officer to protect one another.

The clones also save people who would have died without them. Their courage is part of why the Republic’s treatment of them is so hard to excuse. It asks them to protect people who have the freedom to go home, then leaves a man like Cut to take that freedom for himself.

Order 66 Turned Their Own Bodies Against Them

Just before Order 66, Rex tells Ahsoka that clones have mixed feelings about the war. They know what it’s cost, but it’s also the reason they and their brothers exist. Rex has spent years watching his family die in a war he can barely imagine his life without.

Then his inhibitor chip makes him turn his blasters on Ahsoka. He fights the order long enough to point her toward Fives, whose investigation gives her the clue she needs to find and remove the chip. Fives couldn’t get anyone to stop the plot while he was alive. He still ends up helping save Rex.

Rex raises both blasters during Order 66 in Shattered
Rex during Order 66 in “Shattered.” Lucasfilm / StarWars.com.

Even after Rex gets control of himself back, the men trying to kill them are his brothers. In “Victory and Death,” Ahsoka tells him to set his blasters to stun. They try to get off the ship without killing the troopers hunting them. After the crash, they bury the men they couldn’t save. Ahsoka gets one friend back and has to leave a field of helmets behind.

Winning the War Still Didn’t Give Them a Future

In The Bad Batch, the Empire wants to replace the clones with recruited soldiers. Senator Riyo Chuchi pushes the Senate to make a plan for the men being replaced. She even goes to a clone bar to ask what they need. After years of politicians deciding where to send them, someone finally wants to know what will happen when they have nowhere to report.

Senator Riyo Chuchi in The Bad Batch
Senator Riyo Chuchi in The Bad Batch. Lucasfilm / StarWars.com.

Chuchi helps expose Rampart’s role in the destruction of Kamino. Palpatine uses the evidence to have Rampart arrested and make the case for stormtroopers. He tells the Senate to worry about how readily the clones obeyed Rampart. The obedience Lama Su once bragged about is suddenly a reason to get rid of them.

Years later, in Obi-Wan Kenobi, a clone veteran begs for credits on Daiyu. Some clones find people willing to help them or make lives of their own. This man is left on the street, already worn down by accelerated aging and years of fighting. The government got him into uniform in half the time. Nobody in charge seems to have spent much of that time thinking about where he’d go when he took it off.